APIA Blog

RSS Feed

Landlord held not liable for co-tenants' pets

Monday, January 11, 2021

Re: Whether a landlord is liable for breaching the quiet enjoyment of one tenant for failing to enforce the terms of the tenancy agreement against a co-tenant

Zama v Feng [2020] NZTT Wellington 4276448

This is a strange one. Bear with us.

Alessandro Zama took his landlord to the Tribunal alleging a number of breaches. On the face of it, many if not most certainly look vexatious to us (in fact, the Tribunal dismissed his entire claim). However, one stood out as notable for landlords going forward.

 
Facts
  • In January 2020 Mr Zama joined an existing tenancy as a co-tenant;
  • The tenancy agreement has a no-pet clause; 
  • Unbeknownst to the landlord, two of Mr Zama’s co-tenants kept two cats at the premises. Mr Zama knew about the cats when he moved in;
  • In August 2020, the landlord became aware of the cats through a text message from Mr Zama;
  • Mr Zama issued a 14-day breach notice to the landlord for failure to enforce the no-pet provision in the tenancy agreement;
  • The landlord issued a 14-day notice to the pet-owning co-tenants to re-home the cats but subsequently changed his mind and allowed the cats to stay.
 
The law

Under s38(2) of the Residential Tenancies Act, a landlord must not cause or permit any interference with the reasonable peace, comfort or privacy of the tenant in their use of the premises. 

 

The claim

Mr Zama made a claim against the landlord for $2,000 compensation on the basis that the cats had disturbed his reasonable peace and had it not been the landlord’s failure to enforce the no-pet provision the cats would not be at the property in the first place.

 

Outcome

The Tribunal dismissed the claim citing insufficient evidence proving

  • that the landlord had knowledge of the cats prior to August 2020; and 
  • that the cats had caused any great disruption to Mr Zama’s peace
 
Discussion

While it certainly seems pretty absurd for a tenant to make his landlord liable for actions by his co-tenants, the language of the decision suggests otherwise. 

Yes, the first parties to have committed any breach in this instance were the two cat-owning co-tenants. The obligation to enforce the terms of the tenancy agreement then falls onto the landlord once the breach became known. And it is the failure to discharge this second obligation that made up the breach at the centre of this claim. The weakness of Mr Zama’s claim lies in a lack of evidence to qualify the breach and quantify the loss, not a lack of standing to bring about the claim.

The suggestion is therefore that in the right circumstances and with the right set of facts, the Tribunal would be open to holding a landlord liable for not acting (in a timely fashion) against a tenant who has breached the tenancy agreement to the detriment of a co-tenant.

 

Take-home for landlords
  • In a co-tenancy situation, actions of one tenant could beget an obligation on the landlord to enforce the terms of the tenancy agreement to the benefit of another tenant;
  • Where a tenancy is regularly varied to accommodating the comings and goings of different co-tenants, think long and hard about whether you are prepared to play traffic cop between all the tenants before you agree to take on new co-tenants;
  • When one co-tenant complains about the actions of another, respond in a timely fashion; and
  • Any agreements/concessions made that materially change the terms tenancy agreement should be documented by way of a variation and appropriate notice be given to all co-tenants.

Overall helpfulness scale (Because let's be honest, Tribunal decisions can be a bit of a mess but still, landlords and tenants need all the help we can get!)

⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️


 

Recent Posts


Tags

rtaa2020 wealth creation cash-flow rta insulation trademe RBNZ Standards New Zealand tenancy issues buying rules market rent privacy damage Sponsored post personal growth heater capital gain nzpif brightline mortgage house prices warren buffett Question and answer structure cgt interest rates ird ask an expert landlord auckland property management subdivision early termination DTI worksafe sublease Guest blog first home buying mindset productivity clnz wins p lab anz maintenance skill shortage partners LIM watercare kiwibuild equity shortland chartered accountants housing affordability data security bond form quiet enjoyment lvr recycling equity yield development How to insurance management Market report Must knows Level 4 scotney williams property water bill bond will income rental market opes partners trust warm up new zealand Q&A election 2017 trespass banking HHGA return airbnb building barfoot and thompson Property (Relationships) Act Editor's Choice robert kiyosaki investment strategy business tenant ventilation investor rent re agent ocr inspection rta reform beginner investor gluckman report property apprentice tenancy tribunal off the plan advice education anti-social behaviour Case study shower dome HSWA auckland council buyer's agent bad tenant smoke alarm rent increase meth termination HHS principal and interest covid-19 election2020 commerce commission sale and purchase minor dwelling property cycle Investment tip TCIT ring-fencing television legal asbestos rental wof financial advisers act property value Tribunal case study RTAA 2019 Holler khh letting fee government debt enforcement short-term rental tenancy services property maintenance Must know fixed-term tenancy heating bankruptcy CoreLogic positive cash flow unitary plan interest only reserve bank twg report housing bubble Landlording Gluckman letting parry v inglis sale and purchas Jeff Bezos winz relationship extractor fan initio rent arrears finance CCC meth contamination boarding house renovation negotiation holiday house buying retaliatory notice tax cat speculator market Kris Pedersen Mortgages and Insurance Investor story

Archive

Introducing Our Partners
Principal Sponsor - Kris Pedersen Mortgages & Insurance logo Gold Sponsor - Barfoot & Thompson logo Gold Sponsor - CoreLogic logo Property Apprentice logo The Insulation Warehouse logo The Renovation Team logo The New Zealand Property Investors' Federation logo
09 360 2376
info@apia.org.nz

The Tenancy Practice Service and TPS Credit Control work closely with the Auckland Property Investors' Association. Our vision of bringing helpful resources, documents and high quality services to Auckland Property Investors and Property Managers is shared by APIA, so its a partnership that works well. 

The Auckland Property Investors' Association is a great organisation for those who want access to advice and information from a range of industry experts and partners. 



Mathieu Holt- Managing Director, The Tenancy Practice Service & TPS Credit Control
Through the Association I found the channels and methods to fund the purchase of property I never dreamed about. Grant Brown

All round it has been one of those things Neil and I felt was really worthwhile belonging to. We have learned so much it has just built our confidence in what we are doing.

Janice Bieleski
I read two articles in the monthly magazine that saved me over $5,000. That is my membership fee for the next 26 years and I am sure I will learn a whole lot more! John Duncan
Fantastic organisation. The networking opportunities are brilliant and provide us with information and opportunities that cannot be obtained anywhere else. We learn something new at every meeting and we've been in this game for nearly 20 years. Pauline and Gyanen Kumar

I find the information obtained from various APIA meetings very useful in guiding my own property investment and rental management.  I also enjoy the networking opportunities with like-minded investors.  I am inspired by other investors’ success and find the more experiences and knowledge that I share with others, the more confident I become.  

Thanks to all APIA event organizers and administrators for your brilliant work. 

Stella Shao

I like talking to people and learning from their experience because it gives me the confidence to invest well. I think it is a knowledge thing. I now know I am doing things the right way.

Stephen Weatherall

My APIA membership has become a total success.

Every time I attend a monthly or regional meeting I come away with so many useful and positive tips that have added value to my property investments and management.

Not only that, the website is a great place for practical advice and useful information. It has now evolved into an important resource for my business.

Talk about value for money! The discounts I have been getting at Bunnings when I present my APIA membership card have more than paid for my annual subscription!

Tim Duffett, Plan A Investments Limited